Day 61 | The Common Mistake of Newbies
When building web applications, many developers implement role-based access control (RBAC) to ensure that only authorized users can access certain pages or features. However, a common mistake among newbies is hiding protected routes only on the frontend without properly securing them on the backend. This creates a serious security vulnerability, allowing unauthorized users to bypass client-side restrictions and access sensitive data or functionality. Let’s explore why this happens, the risks involved, and how to fix it properly.
The Mistake: Frontend-Only Protection
Many developers rely on frontend frameworks to handle routing and conditionally display content based on user roles. While this may seem like an effective way to restrict access, it only prevents unauthorized users from seeing certain UI elements. It does not actually prevent them from accessing restricted resources or performing actions directly on the backend.
The frontend is fully accessible to users, meaning they can inspect and modify it using developer tools. If the backend does not have proper role-based authorization, attackers can bypass frontend restrictions and make direct requests to restricted endpoints.
The Risks: Why This Is Dangerous
Direct API Access: Without backend authorization, an attacker can send requests to restricted endpoints using external tools, even if they cannot access them through the UI.
Client-Side Tampering: Since frontend logic runs in the browser, users can modify it to remove restrictions and gain unauthorized access.
Security Through Obscurity Is Not Security: Just because something is hidden on the frontend doesn’t mean it is protected. Sensitive operations remain exposed if the backend does not enforce security.
Unauthorized Data Exposure: If the backend does not validate user roles, attackers may access confidential data intended only for specific roles.
The Fix: Proper Backend Authorization
The correct way to secure protected routes is to enforce RBAC on the backend as well. This means ensuring that every request to sensitive resources is verified against user roles before granting access.
-
Enforce Role-Based Authorization on Every Request
The backend should check the user’s role before processing any request to protected resources. Simply preventing access through the UI is not enough. -
Use Centralized Role-Based Access Control
Instead of implementing role validation separately for each action, a centralized mechanism should handle access control across the application. This reduces redundancy and ensures consistency in security policies. -
Secure API Calls with Authentication and Permissions
Authentication mechanisms such as token-based authentication should be used to verify user identity and role. This ensures that only authorized users can access certain functionalities, even if they attempt to bypass frontend restrictions.